FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Think Tank: £73bn LGPS surplus offers an opportune moment for major pensions reform
LONDON, 7th October 2026 — Trafalgar Analytics' Economics and Growth Team has this week published a policy paper on funded public sector pension schemes in the UK, with the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) in focus.
The paper concludes that, with the LGPS in aggregate surplus, a future government has an opportunity to reform funded public sector pensions, so that they offer better value for taxpayers and are fairer relative to private sector equivalents.
Main Findings: Why reform funded public sector pensions?
Defined Benefit pensions dominate the public sector, whereas Defined Contribution pensions are the norm in the private sector.
Defined Benefit pensions place the investment risk on the taxpayer, whereas Defined Contribution schemes place it on individuals.
The current system for funded public sector pension schemes sees the taxpayer on the hook for billions of liabilities, a stark contrast to the average Defined Contribution scheme largely offered in the private sector.
The paper focuses specifically on funded public sector DB pension schemes, which have assets held in large multi-billion-pound pots, and are as a result more salient to the public and practically easier to reform.
The LGPS is by far the largest funded public sector scheme in the UK, and holds over £400bn of assets.
At 31 March 2025, the LGPS' aggregate funding level was 122%, (i.e. assets / liabilities) representing a c.£73bn surplus.
Main proposals: What would change?
The paper sets out four main reforms:
Merge the LGPS into one fund, pooling assets and liabilities. This would allow for a single national employer contribution rate, as opposed to the individual rates currently in place. Such a reform would significantly cut professional adviser fees through the duplication of work which occurs.
Close the LGPS to future accrual and replace it with a public sector Defined Contribution scheme. This would reduce the long-term burden on the taxpayer and create greater parity with the private sector.
For the existing LGPS assets, firstly create a Ringfenced Portfolio to meet existing members' promised benefits. This would allow risk to be taken off the table, and the assets to be orderly sold down over time to meet the c.7 million members promised payments.
With the £73bn surplus, place this into a Surplus Portfolio, which can be invested with UK strategic interests in mind.
"Public sector pensions should be fair for the taxpayers who fund them," said Stephen Havener, paper co-author and Associate (Economics) at Trafalgar Analytics. "The LGPS surplus gives a future government a window of opportunity to address the fairness aspect in a smooth manner. We set out wholesale reforms that protect what has been promised to around seven million existing members and puts the taxpayer funded surplus to work in the national interest."
Supplementary Proposals: What else could be done?
The paper also recommends smaller strategic, governance and legislative changes which can be considered as more short-term changes to the current framework.
Strategic: increase passive equity exposure, remove equity protection strategies, move gilt holdings into British infrastructure, add an allocation to assets in the "national interest", and limit 'private market' exposure.
Governance: improve councillors' knowledge of their powers on pension committees, remove the requirement to consider ESG factors under fiduciary duty, increase accountability over the Pools' hiring, and close the MPs' DB pension scheme (the PCPF) to future accrual in favour of a DC arrangement.
Legislative: most changes can be made through changes to the LGPS (Pooling, Management and Investment of Funds) Regulations 2026, while ending the MPs' current DB pension scheme and any change to fiduciary duty would likely need an Act of Parliament.
How Should the Debate Be Framed?
It is anticipated that the proposed reforms would face strong pushback from stakeholders who have significant vested interests in the current system.
To help frame the public debate, the paper proposes new terms:
"Benefit Payment Reserve" for the ringfenced assets,
"Strategic UK Growth Fund" for the surplus,
"Taxpayer Contributions" in place of "Employer Contributions".
The paper is the first in a series on pensions reform. A paper on reforming the unfunded public sector pension schemes will follow.
Additional Information
The full policy paper, "Addressing Public Sector Funded Pension Schemes", is available here, and on Substack, here.
Media Contact
Sarah Moore (Senior Communications Officer), Trafalgar Analytics
media@trafalgaranalytics.co.uk
ENDS
Follow Trafalgar Analytics on X/Twitter (here), or subscribe for free to our Substack newsletter to receive the latest updates of our upcoming papers:
NOTES TO EDITORS
The authors of the policy paper, Stephen Havener and James Fairbank, are Associates in the Economics and Growth Team at Trafalgar Analytics.
"Addressing Public Sector Funded Pension Schemes" is available here.
For more information or interview requests, please contact Sarah Moore on media@trafalgaranalytics.co.uk.
Trafalgar Analytics is a British data analytics and research centre. Its work sits at the intersection between data science, economics, and political science. It believes in a data driven approach for tackling the foremost societal, economic, and political challenges of our time.